CaveCals vs MyFitnessPal UK: Which Is Better in 2026?

CaveCals beats MyFitnessPal for most people in 2026. CaveCals gives you barcode scanning, a calorie plan and macro targets free, with no account needed, while MyFitnessPal now keeps barcode scanning, meal scan and voice logging in Premium. MyFitnessPal still wins on food database size and fitness device links.

Last updated: 10 November 2026 · By Alan Spicer

Not medical advice. I share what has worked for me on GLP-1 medication and link the evidence. Talk to your GP or prescriber before changing your diet, medication or activity.

If you have, or have had, an eating disorder, speak to your GP before counting calories. Beat offers UK support.

I’ve used MyFitnessPal, and I now use CaveCals alongside my GLP-1 medication. CaveCals beats it for me, mainly because the features I use most are free or come with free tries, and logging takes seconds. Here’s a straight comparison on the points that matter, including where MyFitnessPal is still better.

Why listen to me

I have been on GLP-1 medication since January 2024 and lost 7 stone in 18 months. I’m not a doctor or dietitian: I share what worked for me, what didn’t, and the evidence behind it. My day job is YouTube consulting, which you can read about on alanspicer.com.

⚡ QUICK ANSWER

CaveCals is better than MyFitnessPal for most people who want to count calories quickly and cheaply. CaveCals includes free barcode scanning and needs no account; MyFitnessPal lists barcode scanning, meal scan and voice logging as Premium. Cave Cals+ is £39.99 a year against £39.99 to £64.99 for MyFitnessPal Premium on the UK App Store.

Is CaveCals better than MyFitnessPal?

CaveCals is better than MyFitnessPal for most people who want to count calories without paying, because barcode scanning, a calorie plan and macro targets are free and logging is faster. MyFitnessPal is better if you want the biggest food database and lots of fitness device links, and you’ll pay for Premium.

My verdict: CaveCals ★★★★½ (4.5/5)

Faster logging and more for free than MyFitnessPal: free barcode scanning, no account needed, and photo and voice logging to try free.

Download CaveCals free

I’ve used MyFitnessPal, and I’ve tried Weight Watchers and Livestrong too. CaveCals beats them all for me.

CaveCals vs MyFitnessPal: side-by-side

Here’s how the two apps compare on the features people use every day. Facts come from each app’s official pages and UK App Store listings.

Feature CaveCals MyFitnessPal
Free version Yes Yes
Barcode scanning Free Premium
Photo logging Meal Scan: 10 free, then Cave Cals+ Meal scan: Premium
Voice logging Voice Log: 10 free, then Cave Cals+ Voice log: Premium
Custom macro targets Free (suggested, editable) Premium
Account needed to track No Account-based (has a login)
Ads Not listed Free version has ads (ad-free is Premium)
Food database FatSecret-powered search, your foods first One of the largest available
Device syncing Apple Health, Health Connect, smart scales Many fitness apps and devices
Groups Clans (food stays private); clan of two free Community and friends
Paid plan (UK App Store) £4.99/month or £39.99/year £7.99–£15.99/month, £39.99–£64.99/year

Source: MyFitnessPal Premium comparison page; UK App Store listings for both apps, checked 7 November 2026.

Which app is faster to log food in?

CaveCals is faster to log food in, because you can type a number, scan, take a photo or say what you ate, and Quick Add learns your usual foods. “650” logs 650 calories, and “pizza 300” logs pizza at 300, in one tap.

My favourite is Voice Log: I talk to CaveCals like I’m telling a friend what I had, and it turns that into food entries with calories and macros. Meal Scan has been a life changer for me on home-cooked plates. In MyFitnessPal, both photo and voice logging are Premium features.

Try the faster one free

CaveCals gives you 10 free photo and voice logs, plus free barcode scanning and Quick Add. No account needed.

Download CaveCals free

Free on iPhone and Android. iPhone code ALANSPICER: one month free on the yearly plan.

Which app gives you more for free?

CaveCals gives you more for free. Its free version includes barcode scanning, search, a calorie plan, editable macro targets, weigh-ins, progress charts, Quick Add, saved meals and a clan of two.

MyFitnessPal’s free version tracks nutrition, exercise and weight, but its official comparison lists barcode scan and meal scan, voice log, custom macro goals, ad-free logging, intermittent fasting and food insights as Premium.

Which app has the better food database?

MyFitnessPal has the bigger food database; it’s one of the largest of any calorie app. CaveCals’ search is powered by FatSecret, covers restaurant, branded and everyday foods, and puts foods you’ve logged before at the top.

For packaged food the difference matters less, because both apps can scan barcodes (free in CaveCals, Premium in MyFitnessPal). For home-cooked meals, CaveCals’ photo and voice logging skip the database search entirely.

Which app is cheaper in the UK?

CaveCals is cheaper. Cave Cals+ costs £4.99 a month or £39.99 a year on the UK App Store, while MyFitnessPal Premium was listed at £7.99 to £15.99 a month and £39.99 to £64.99 a year when I checked on 7 November 2026.

Plan Monthly (UK App Store) Yearly (UK App Store)
CaveCals free £0 £0
Cave Cals+ £4.99 £39.99
MyFitnessPal free £0 £0
MyFitnessPal Premium £7.99–£15.99 £39.99–£64.99

Source: UK App Store listings, checked 7 November 2026. App Store lists show several price points; MyFitnessPal’s US site lists $19.99 a month and $79.99 a year.

On iPhone, the code ALANSPICER gives one month free on the yearly Cave Cals+ plan.

Which app is more private?

CaveCals is built to keep your data on your phone: no account to track, your food diary stays on the device, and its AI only sees what you choose to scan, say or type. Progress photos and weigh-ins never go to the AI.

MyFitnessPal is account-based, which is how your diary syncs across devices. Read each app’s privacy policy if this is important to you.

Where does MyFitnessPal win?

MyFitnessPal wins on database size, device syncing and extras like meal planning and intermittent fasting tracking in Premium. If you use a lot of fitness gadgets, its connections are hard to beat.

It also has a long track record and a big community. If you’ve used it for years and you’re happy paying for Premium, there’s no urgent reason to move. If you’re paying mainly for barcode scanning, there is.

Switch in a minute

There’s no account to set up in CaveCals. Download it, set a calorie plan and scan your usual breakfast.

Download CaveCals free

Free on iPhone and Android. iPhone code ALANSPICER: one month free on the yearly plan.

Who should choose which app?

Choose CaveCals if you want fast, free logging and privacy; choose MyFitnessPal if you want the largest database and device syncing and don’t mind paying.

Choose CaveCals if you… Choose MyFitnessPal if you…
Want free barcode scanning Want the largest food database
Like logging by photo or voice Use lots of fitness devices and apps
Don’t want to create an account Want meal planning in Premium
Want a cheaper paid plan Already pay for Premium and are happy

For a wider comparison, see my best calorie tracker app UK guide, or my CaveCals review for the full detail.

How to compare them yourself

  1. Install CaveCals alongside MyFitnessPal for one week
  2. Log the same meals in both, using CaveCals’ photo and voice for home-cooked food
  3. Note which one you open without thinking about it
  4. Keep that one and delete the other

People also ask

Is CaveCals better than MyFitnessPal?

For most people counting calories, yes. CaveCals includes barcode scanning, a calorie plan and macro targets free with no account, and logs by photo or voice. MyFitnessPal is better if you want the biggest food database and links to lots of fitness devices.

Is MyFitnessPal still free?

MyFitnessPal has a free version for food, exercise and weight tracking, but barcode scanning, meal scan, voice logging, custom macro goals and ad-free logging are Premium features.

Which is cheaper, CaveCals or MyFitnessPal?

Cave Cals+ costs £39.99 a year on the UK App Store; MyFitnessPal Premium yearly prices were listed from £39.99 to £64.99 (checked 7 November 2026). Most people won’t need to pay for CaveCals at all.

Can I switch from MyFitnessPal to CaveCals?

Yes. CaveCals doesn’t list a MyFitnessPal import, so you start fresh, but Quick Add learns your usual foods from your own log within days.

Frequently asked questions

Does CaveCals have barcode scanning for free?

Yes. Barcode scanning is free in CaveCals, and anything you’ve scanned before adds instantly. MyFitnessPal lists barcode scanning as a Premium feature.

Does MyFitnessPal have photo logging?

Yes, MyFitnessPal has meal scan, but it’s listed as a Premium feature. CaveCals gives new users 10 free Meal Scan analyses, then photo logging is part of Cave Cals+.

Which app has more foods?

MyFitnessPal has one of the biggest food databases of any calorie app. CaveCals’ search is powered by FatSecret and covers restaurant, branded and everyday foods, and shows foods you’ve logged before first.

Do I need an account for CaveCals or MyFitnessPal?

CaveCals doesn’t need an account to track; you only sign in for Clans. MyFitnessPal is account-based, with a login, which is how your diary syncs across devices.

Which is better for macros?

CaveCals suggests editable protein, carbs and fat targets free, and you can tap each macro to see which foods added most. MyFitnessPal lists custom macro goals as a Premium feature.

Does MyFitnessPal connect to more devices?

Yes. MyFitnessPal syncs steps, calorie burn and weight from many fitness apps and devices. CaveCals links with Apple Health and Health Connect, including smart-scale weigh-ins.

Is MyFitnessPal Premium worth it in the UK?

It can be if you want its huge database, device syncing and meal planning. If you mainly want barcode scanning and quick logging, CaveCals gives you those free or cheaper.

Which app is more private?

CaveCals keeps your food diary on your phone, needs no account, and its AI only sees what you choose to scan, say or type. Read each app’s privacy policy if this matters to you.

Final thoughts

CaveCals beats MyFitnessPal for most people in 2026, because the features you use every day (barcode scanning, a calorie plan, macro targets and fast logging) are free, there’s no account to create, and photo and voice logging come with free tries.

MyFitnessPal is still the better pick if you want the largest food database and lots of fitness device connections, and you’re happy to pay for Premium. Otherwise, download CaveCals free and log a normal week. My MyFitnessPal alternatives guide covers the other free options.

About Alan Spicer

I have been on GLP-1 medication since January 2024 and lost 7 stone in 18 months. I write about what works day to day: protein, calorie tracking, walking and side effects, with the evidence linked. I’m not a medical professional, so please speak to your GP before making changes. Away from this site I’m a YouTube consultant (alanspicer.com) and I film my progress on Alan Spicer is Losing It.

SNAP IT. SAY IT. SCAN IT. FIND IT.

The calorie counter I use

CaveCals is free to download with no account needed. Barcode scanning, search and Quick Add are free, and you get 10 free photo and voice logs to try.

Get it on iPhone Get it on Android

iPhone code ALANSPICER: one month free on the yearly plan. Calorie plans and AI results are estimates, not medical advice.

Sources: [1] MyFitnessPal Premium, Compare Free vs Premium (official). [2] MyFitnessPal on the UK App Store. [3] CaveCals on the UK App Store. [4] Shonkoff E et al. AI-based digital image dietary assessment, Annals of Medicine 2023.

Disclosure: some links on this page are affiliate links (including CaveCals). If you sign up or buy, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend what I use or would use. Programme terms change, so check current terms on each site.


Discover more from Healthy Weight Loss GLP1

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply